Some more photos from last week's solo test game of my "Chop Sockey! Kung Fu Miniature Wargame Rules." I made some changes to them this week.
In other projects, I have done some studying on the history or pseudo of ninjas, dug several files of academic papers on a many subjects out of storage for possible projects, and begun some reading on the history of proto-scientific thought in China for a couple projects. I also submitted a couple book reviews on conspiracy thinking to the skeptical inquirer. And I primed a few figures that now need painting.
Let me also off you think link to a piece of interesting history:
Greetings. Hello there boys and girls. Well over a year or two ago, I began working on writing "Chop Sockey!!," a set of rules for kung fu comic or movie style wargames. The results are promising. A friend and I play tested them once, and then, like so many other things, along came the pandemic and that put an end to shared playtesting.
Alas!
Having finished writing my book on Trump (yes, this is a plug, Feel free to buy it. Link below) and anxious to begin work on a new project, I pulled out the rules and gave them a test run playing solo.
Basic scenario concept was to have a group of innocents being mistreated by bad people and some heroes need to come, intervene, and give them a chance to escape.
Looking for suitable bad guys, I chose my recently painted "steam punky" Dead Rabbits gang.
Now for the good guys, I realized that while I had suitable civilian figures, I had no rules for civilians, at least not yet.. (They shall be written soon and will be finished by next solo game. I promise. The stats for civilians will give them very low, combat ability but high saves. This way, they don't really add much to combat but they do stay around long enough to be rescued.)
For the good guys, I chose suitable Chinese Boxer rebellion or Taiping Uprising figures, creating a group of generic mobs of ten men with spears, swords, and muskets. I faced them off against each other at one corner of a four by four card table. I then put two suitable kung fu heroes at the farthest corner of the table.
I called the scenario "We wuz just funnin' the Chinaman!" as an homeage to the classic 1970s TV show Kung Fu which chronicles the adventures of Kwai-Chiang Kane, a half breed Shaolin monk who wondered the old American west. An interesting show that shaped American images of kung fu and the martial arts in its early days, a common event in the series was that Kane would wonder into a western town. Soon after the local, inbred white trash with bad teeth would begin hassling him because he was Chinese and did not really fit in in that neighborhood, and go further and further with their hassling. Kane would inevitablly lecture them with Chinese philosophy (or the 1970s AmericanTV version of Chinese philosophy --think fortune cookie philosophy), that would fail, they would then attack him, and he would kick in half a dozen peoples teeth, leaving them on the ground whining "But we wuz just funnin' the Chinaman, and he done kicked our teeth all in!"
Alas, good stuff. If you've never seen the show, your education is lacking something.
Anyway, that's sort of what I was going for here. My results were mixed.
Game Forces
The Dead Rabbits -a particular colorful group of White Trash and Irish Trash, no less
Unit One: Seven Dead Rabbits
Classified as "Warriors" -each unit consists of a standard bearer with a Dead Rabbit on a pole and five men with clubs or swords and one with a firearm
Unit Two: Seven Dead Rabbits
Also classified as "Warriors" and equipped identically to the first unit although one was actually a woman and not a man -not that this makes any difference in these rules. It does, however, add color to the table top.
Liam Angus McGutstab O'Heaney
A widely feared drunken berserker. He was classified as a hero but given no chi points (He may conceivably have great chi. No one actually knows as he's simply too drunk and uncouth to know how to use it anyway if he does. I am, by the way, very proud of the figure. He's a conversion from, of all things, a Gaul gladiator, and I'm quite proud of him. See my old posts on the subject.)
Ook Ook O'Brien
A gorilla in a top hat. He escaped from the circus and was taken in by the Dead Rabbits. They were eager to have him, because they needed some better educated, more sophisticated, better travelled members and, being as he was widely travelled with the circus, he met the bill and filled the void.
Ook Ook is classified in the rules as a gorilla. Yes, there are rules for gorillas and other animals and I was hoping to try them out. Besides, it is a rule of thumb among wargamers, if you have a figure of gorilla in a top hat, put that figure in a game almost any chance you can.
The Good Hearted Chinese
Three units of ten Chinese tong members classified as "fighters" armed with swords, spears and a few muskets. Each had a standard bearer.
Two Kung Fu heroes at the far end of the table. These were unarmed but each had four points of "chi."
Victory Conditions
The Chinese must escape off the far corner of the board with two thirds of their forces intact.
Turn One
To determine which side went first a simple pair of dice were rolled for each side. The Dead Rabbits won.
The turn sequence involves moving the units on a side, one by one, and then taking each unit through the entire turn sequence.
Since the Dead Rabbits had four "units" -two seven man gangs, the gorilla, and the drunken berserker hero- this would mean four units would move through their sequence.
The first Dead Rabbit gang charged at the middle of the Chinese units.
Being Warriors they had automatic activation and since they were charging they got double movement. Thus they moved ahead 8 inches, made contact with a group of Chinese seven or less inches away, and hand to hand fighting broke out.
The attackers were classified as warriors and got 2 dice per figure or 14 dice total.
The defenders were classified as fighters and got 1 dice each or 10 dice total.
The dice were rolled and the Dead Rabbits inflicted 6 hits on the Chines tong members. The Chinese rolled their saving dice and only one of the six saved. Of the five hit, dice were rolled for the hit resul and three were wounded and two were dead.
In that melee the Chinese caused three hits on the Dead Rabbits, killing two and wounding one.
The second unit of Dead Rabbits charged the nearest unit of Chinese tong members and inflicted 7 hits.
The hero and the gorilla were blocked from charging any of the other Chinese due to having the two melees taking place in front of them so they just advanced at normal speed and took up a position in support of the brawling gangs.
Nevertheless, after the first turn, it was very obvious that the Chinese side was definitely way outclassed. Classifying all the forces on one side as "warriors," a designation intended for elite soldiers and their tribal or feudal equivalents, was a mistake. It had produced a very lop-sided battle. (Of course, I have thoughts on how to modify this in the future.)
Chinese Phase of the First Turn
The Chinese side had five "units." These were the two heroes far to the rear and the three 10 man units of Tong fighters, two of which had taken heavy casualties already and were greatly weakened.
Since the victory condition for the Chinese were to get as many figures to safety as possible, the untouched unit of Tong fighters decided to flee at double speed. In hindsight, I'm not sure this was a good idea, but, as they say, it seemed like a good idea at the time.
One of the heroes decided to charge into combat and to use lots of Chi to speed his entry. A normal charge or running move for a hero is 8 inches. For each point of Chi used, a hero can add 4 inches to his move. Using three points, he moved a total of 20 inches (8 + 12) and charged into combat with one of the Dead Rabbit gangs. He decided to go for broke and use his remaining chi point to add to his combat effectivness.
Alas! Despite some heavy modifiers for that turn -the result of him using his chi- one hero versus seven warriors is a fight where the seven warriors have a strong advantage. A couple warriors left took hits and left the game but this meant that there were still five of them and one hero with no chi points, all alone against them and their nearby friends.
The other hero saved his chi and moved 8 inches towards the center of the action.
The remnants of the badly mauled units attempted to flee, but due to their wounds were not able. (If a character has a wound, he must consult a chart and pass a dice roll before perform actions such as fighting or moving. While a character can have multiple wounds, he must pass a dice roll for each and every wound or he cannot perform that action. The characters rolled badly and could not flee.)
Turn Two -- Dead Rabbits Phase
The two units of Dead Rabbits pursued or attacked the two units of Chinese tong members and the hero who supported them. They inflicted some more casualities but not enough to change the flow of the battle.
The gorilla and the hero still found themselves waiting in support, watching, ready, but still not actually doing anything.
Turn Two --Chinese Phase
There were three units of tong fighters.
One was undamaged but had chosen to flee. This was intended to increase the forces chances of meeting the victory conditions. In hindsight this might have been a bad idea, as the Dead Rabbits had already achieved their victory conditions, and it had become obvious that the scenario was probably quite unbalanced.
The two Chinese heroes found themselves touching bases and formed a unit. This allowed them to activate and move together, as well as pool their dice in combat.
Alas, when they entered combat, they found themselves outclassed by the large number of Dead Rabbits they were facing. Not only did they inflict little damage on the Dead Rabbits but one fo the heroes took hits and missed his saves and was killed and removed from the game. This left just one hero, one unwounded tong fighter, and several wounded tong fighters faced off against an overwhelming force of enemy warriors supported by a hero and a gorilla in a top hat.
Turn Three -FLEEEEE!!!
Seeing no other real option, the tong fighters fled the table.
ANALYSIS
As a game, not terribly successful, but as a game testing or rule testing session a lot was learned about balancing scenarios. Several rules were tweaked afterwards. Others were added.
Are they finished? Absolutely not. But you can take a peak at what they look like so far. Stay tuned and for the moment, read on and how cast metal got to this point and then come back and see where it goes to.
Greetings! While new at blogging, I do know that the key to successful blogging is consistency and reliability. Alas, neither comes easily to me, and I realize that I am a few days behind in offering content. Yet, while busy, busy, busy, and disrupted by a now occurring historic event called the Covid-19 Pandemic, I have still spent time on wargaming and modelling projects. And with that in mind, I offer an update on my current miniature wargaming project, a sort of semi-historical, "Steampunkish," "Victorian SF." Weird West kind-of representation of the Dead Rabbits gang described in mid-nineteenth century American newspapers and the book and film Gangs of New York. Little by little, evening by evening, I've done some work on this project and here it is.
The figures have been primed and based and a little bit of color (is gray a color?) have been added.
The gray is finished for the moment.
And then came the dark brown.
Followed by a black, the end result of a relaxing evening spent on a silly hobby project.
Next came a dark, almost maroon red.
A few different colors including a dark skin tone are now added.
Getting closer to the detail work. I enjoy the detail work. If I didn't, well, it wouldn't be worth doing, would it?
And now, the detail work begins . . .
(Is it finished? Absolutely not. To see the finished project and the completed figures, you will have to come back to a later installment in this blog. Hopefully, if fate wills it, coming soon. Remember. These are not done yet. Works in progress.)
A look at some of the gang. Again, about two thirds finished. Those eyes need some touching up as do the weapons.
Some random gang members.
A close up of the two command figures. The calculating, cunning, always planning gang leader and the Irish Roman Catholic Priest. I figure these figures are about two thirds finished. I also think those eyes are way too big and need some touching up. It will happen. Come back and see.
Works in progress. Dead Rabbits Gang members. And, yes, my photography skills could stand a bit of improvement.
Another view of the partially finished command figures.
Another close up of the half finished command figures.
Stay tuned for the final project.
Books and Media for the period.
There is a variety of media one can get if you wish to explore this period of American history in more depth. Please remember, if you order through these links you are supporting this website.
First, once again, we have this wonderful set of rules.
Second, we have Herbert Asbury's classic yet sensationalized work, "Gangs of New York." Asbury was writing in the 1920s about life in the mid-nineteenth century and historians who look it over pretty much universally feel he was more interested in entertaining the reader than sticking to the facts and presenting a historically accurate document. It's an entertaining read that has been through several editions, but should not be taken as gospel. This is probably why when you look for more details and other sources on some of the things he describes you simply don't find them, as it is likely that they never existed.
Tyler Anbinder's "Five Points: The 19th Century New York City Neighborhood that Invented Tap Dance, Stole Elections, and Became the World's Most Notorious Slum," is a more serious history of the time and place written by a contemporary author. The two books at times contradict each other.
The Great Riots of New York is a late nineteenth century work that describes historical events as the author understood them to have happened. It is probably one of the sources Asbury used to write his book and parts of it are well worth reading to understand this period.
Yes, there was a big Hollywood movie based on these things and the events in Asbury's book. Perhaps unexpectedly, I was not a particularly big fan of the film, neither are the people at TVAG either by the way, they make that clear in the introduction to their wonderful rules, and it is also not particularly accurate in its depiction of history. Dates are mixed and some of the details not quite right. Nevertheless, if you are going to game this period, it's gotta be a "must-see" film so, if you wish, consider buying it through this link.
I was a bigger fan of a much lesser known BBC-America show called "Copper," which portrayed the adventures of a New York City police detective during the American Civil War. The show ran for two short seasons only and the actual number of episodes is a bit limited but it was a very interesting series and gives an interesting depiction of the underside of the City of New York at the time, even if it does not mention any of Asbury's gangs. Be forewarned that is a very dark and at times difficult to watch series but very well done. For instance, several episodes of the first season deal with the main character's attempts to get a 12 year old prostitute off of the streets and into a better life. She is portrayed disturbingly realistically. The situation is complicated when it turns out she is fleeing an abusive, yet completely legal, marriage to a man three or four times her age, and the legal options under the laws of the time are quite limited when he announces he wants her back. (The age of marriage at that time was much, much lower than now.) Worth watching if the period interests you and you can stomach dark materials.
Please be aware-
while there are only two seasons of the show available, they are being sold in several different packages so there are six items listed below.
And one more time, the awesome rules . . .
Finally, my books . . .
Yeah, I've written books. Please check them out and see if they interest you.
In the mid-nineteenth century, according to some reports, the neighborhoods of the City of New York were dominated by fearsome gangs. One of these, according to these reports, was the Irish gang from the Five Points neighborhood known as the Dead Rabbits.
If you've read the first two installments in this series, then you know that several manufacturers make figures and rules for wargaming the conflicts, battles, and riots involving these gangs. However, for better or worse, if you've read the second installment, you know that the history of these gangs, up to and including whether there was a real Dead Rabbits gang, is controversial.
Which leads a wargamer intent on gaming the period with a dilemma. What's a guy to do when he's intent on painting a bunch of figures to represent that seem to have never actually existed as described? Well, as any good gamer knows, paint on!! Huzzah and Hurray!! Never let reality get in the way of painting figures if they are figures you truly wish to paint! And, if they are not a real thing, then use as much imagination and pizzazz as possible and if done right, and the results are impressive enough, no one can possibly complain!
And thus I made my decision to create a reproduction of the Dead Rabbits, not as they may or may not have been, but as they should have been regardless of whether or not they actually existed. In other words, I have sort of taken reality as a jumping off point and am working on sort of a steampunky sort of Dead Rabbits gang.
And to do this, I needed a few special figures. Fortunately not only are there a lot of interesting figures out there waiting to be bought, prepped for gaming, and painted, but converting figures into something special and unique is a fun part of the hobby.
The five special figures I bought or converted for my Dead Rabbits Gang. From left to right, a standard bearer marching off to battle with a Dead Rabbit on a pole, a female Dead Rabbit with a cavalry or naval saber, a drunken Irish street berserker, a second standard bearer proudly holding another dead rabbit on a pike, and, of course, a gorilla in a top hat. One must have a gorilla in a top hat, after all, or something is lacking from your Dead Rabbits gang. If your opponent should object to the presence of a gorilla in a top hat in a historical game, well, your choices are simple either put the gorilla in the top hat back in the box and get on with the game (if he wishes to be historically sound and all) or get a new opponent and put the one who objects out on the street instead. Regardless, the presence of a gorilla in a top hat among your figures does not require that such a figure be used in every game, but it most does increase your options when preparing for a game. And, it looks cool.
A second view of the figures under construction.
Below, I will describe the figures and the work done on them.
First, an introduction to converting figures. In order to convert or modify a miniature figure, you need the proper tools and supplies. A good Exacto or hobby knife is required but here's some of the other supplies I used.
"Green stuff" --sculptable epoxy putty. One cuts or tears off a bit,
mixes the two colors together, kneads carefully until it all turns
green, then stick on to a figure or sculpt as desired. It is sticky and
takes a bit of practice to work with, but you can do fun stuff with it.
It used to be available in mainstream hardware stores but these days
it now only seems to be available from specialty hobby stores.
Games Workshop sells it but, again, you can also but it from
the Army Builder Company.
A good hobby drill with small drill bits was required. This one is so old I have no idea who made it or where I obtained it, but I saw that a similar drill is now available from the Army Builder company. I do not own their drill but their other supplies have worked quite well for me.
Be advised, while I have bought their products several times in hobby stores and been pleased with the results, I have never ordered off of their website. My guess is, though, that if there were problems with their service, I probably would have heard it.
Of course, you will need some "crazy glue" or cyanoacrylite. This comes from several companies in differing qualities and containers. I've found that Loctite Super Glue Gel Control works well and comes in a container where one is unlikely to discover that you have accidentally glued the gap on tight, usually rendering the product worthless and useless and in need of replacement. I like the stuff.
Someone told me that J-B Weld Super Weld is stronger and it's a liquid, not a gel, so I keep some of that around too.
The Original Figures
I decided that if I were going to model a unit of Dead Rabbit gang members charging into battle with standard bearers waving dead rabbits on pikes in the front, I needed a couple more such standard bearers. And some other distinctive and unusual looking figures would be nice to have too.
I dug through the "Gangs of New York" figures I'd purchased and found two that I thought would make nice standard bearers. Then I looked around to see what else I might have that could be used to create distinctive figures. I found these.
The top two gang members looked like they would make good standard bearers. They are, I believe, both from the good people at The Victorian Arm Chair General. ( look around here. You should find them: http://www.thevirtualarmchairgeneral.com/211-bhoysfigs2.html )
Clearly, he's a big, hairy, northern European barbarian condemned to the arena. Some time ago, I ordered a bunch of Roman Gladiator figures off of ebay and wound up with three of these guys, so this seemed like an excellent place to try to put one to use. More on him later.
Dead Rabbit Standard Bearers
This was a relatively simple conversion. First I took the two figures, trimmed the flash (mold lines) and excess metal from them with a hobby knife, then I glued them on to pennies for bases. I do this with most of the figures in a unit. That way they have uniform sized bases.
Next, with the hobby knife, I cut off their clubs. Obviously I put them on a small piece of scrap wood first.
Next thing I needed was the pikes or spears that would become the standards. For these I dug in my spare parts box (any good modelling hobbyist should have a box full of spare parts that he can dig into and pull things out of for projects in the future) and found some Old Glory miniatures spears.
Old Glory 25s in the USA makes many interesting and useful figures at good prices, but their spears and pikes are particularly useful, in my opinion. Made of sturdy piano wire with a molded metal head, unlike the spears on many figures, they don't break. In fact, they make an excellent source of replacement spears for when the spears and pikes on your 25 and 28mm figures break off. I recommend them highly.
But you will also need some little dead rabbits to put on the pikes, now, won't you?
I could think of two sources for these. The first was to sculpt a little dead rabbit out of green stuff, which I did for one figure. The second was to buy a little 28mm rabbit and drill a hole through it and put it through the pike. Of course, it's tough to find some 28mm rabbits.
Not impossible, Reaper Miniatures does have some 28mm Jackalopes. (see: https://www.reapermini.com/miniatures/savage%20worlds/latest/59024 ) which interestingly I do have a pair of but I did not wish to destroy them and put them on a pike. (Hmmm? Might they make an ally to the Dead Rabbits? Or an enemy? Interesting idea)
These are not my Jackalopes but the professionally painted Jackalopes painted by the people at Reaper Miniatures.
Fortunately in my parts box I did have some 28 mm cats. Again, we have the fine folks at Reaper Miniatures to blame or thank for this, depending on one's frame of mind. Some time ago, they came out with a figure of a "crazy cat lady." I lived upstairs from a former belly dancer turned crazy cat lady for a couple years, a sad and frustrating experience but so typically a Schenectady one, so I had to have a 28mm crazy cat lady. She pops up in some of my science fiction or wild west gunfight games. Here's the Reaper Miniature. You can see she came with a lot of extra cats. My extra cats wound up in the parts box. (If you want to buy your own crazy cat lady, https://www.reapermini.com/search/cat%20lady/latest/50235 )
Extra 28mm Cats from the parts box. Courtesy of the figure above.
So I took an extra cat, removed it from the sprue and drilled a hole through it and ran the spear shaft through the hole. You can see this below.
(those cat-like things at the top of the picture?
You can see the resulting standard. You will also note that I did some sculpting with the hobby knife on the figures hand to completely remove the club and prepare it for holding the standard.
Later I removed the cat's long tail with a hobby knife and added some ears and a tail to it using green stuff so it would look more rabbit like. The result is below.
Note that with both of my standard bearer conversions I did drill a small hole in the base of the figure where I could insert the end of the pike and create a stronger hold.
For the second standard bearer, I took a completely different strategy and just sculpted a tiny dead rabbit out of green stuff and ran the wire handle of the spear through it. It appears like I did not take many work in progress pictures as I did but you can see the half completed result below. The standard with the green stuff rabbit lies on the wood while the figure that was prepared for it is in the center, second from left.
Dead Rabbit Crazed Drunken Berserker
This one was a lot of fun. (Yeah, I've got my own sense of fun.)
You will recall we started with the north European barbarian gladiator figure with two swords. I chose him because he was sitting around, unused and looked shaggy, unwashed, and savage, something I wanted in at least one member of my Dead Rabbits gang.
I decided that to make him into a 19th Century drunken Irish brawler, I'd need to give him some pants, modify the swords, and give him a hat. I thought he looked pretty scary if armed and shirtless, as some dangerous drunks tend to be, and actually went so far as to try and trim down his sandal straps to make him barefoot, but a hat seemed like a really good idea and I wasn't quite sure where I'd get one.
Fortunately the gorilla figure, the one I am so proud to own, came with not just a top hat but a tiny bowler cap that looked just right for this figure.
Not sure where to begin exactly I drilled a hold partway into the top of his head. If this confuses you, don't worry. It will become clear later as to why I did this. You can see the little bowler hat next to him and you can see that I had already drilled a hole right smack through the hat itself.
After this was done the next step was to prepare for the addition of pants by removing much of the loincloth with a hobby knife. Obviously, this had to be done carefully so that I did not cut my fingers.
You should be able to see here if you look carefully that chunks of the loincloth have been removed.
Next came the process of adding the pants using the green stuff. This had to be done a little bit at a time over many days a little bit at a time. Of course, I wasn't worried overly much about getting too much, as I knew I'd trim it down when done, but I had to add just a little to get it to stick and then dry in place. Working with green stuff can be tricky as it is sticky, especially when doing detail work on something this small.
Here's some pictures of the work in progress.
This is the final result prior to trimming the green stuff with the hobby knife.
Now, remember the hole I drilled in his head? Remember the hole drilled through the bowler hat?
Now it's time to still a short piece of wire or pin in that hole, zap it in place with the Loctite gel, and let it dry. While at it, it seemed a good time in the process to glue the figure to a penny and trim those Roman era long swords into nineteenth century daggers, again using the hobby knife.
Next slide the bowler hat down the wire.
After that snip off the excess wife and glue it all in place with the loctite gel.
Why not just glue on the hat with the cyanoacrylate? Simple, if you do it that way, it will fall off. Sooner or later that glue will crack and it will fall off. At least that's my experience, so it's a good idea to drill and pin, then glue if you wish a strong bond that will last.
And there you have it!! A crazed, drunken, mid-nineteenth century streets of New York berserker with no shirt and a bowler hat. I'm frighteningly proud of the results, of course.
Dead Rabbits Female Slugger (a Mort? )
I decided my gang needed a female member. Not a woman who stood by the sides and threw bricks, but one who actually waded into the middle of a big, ugly brawl, and made her presence known. But where to find one?
Since Reaper Minis has all kinds of interesting and unusual figures, they seemed the place to go.
I found this figure and decided she'd work fine for the job. "Red Petal Su" --I'm not sure what she's supposed to be but she looks like a woman pirate of the late 17th, early 18th century. Good enough. Context is everything. She's a mid-nineteenth century Gangs of New York Dead Rabbit now.
As you can see, her stand was much larger than a penny though. I decided to fix that. (And, by the way, I always feel guilty when I glue a figure on to Abraham Lincoln's face but it seems better than putting him face down on the ground.) As you can see elsewhere, I cut off that metal slab from the bottom of her feet, the one that fits into the slot, and simply glued her to the penny using the cyanoacrylate. You can see photos of the end result elsewhere on this blog.
Dead Rabbits Gorilla
When I saw this on the Brigade Miniatures website, I knew I had to have it. It comes from Westwind Miniatures Empire of the Dead range, a steam punk range featured in the first blog post in this series.
A photo of the figure in the package.
The opened package, a figure, a plastic stand, and two hats! How lucky I was that it came with not just one but two hats!! Many thanks to the folks at Westwind Figures.
Preparing the figure for painting took very little work. I used some of the green stuff to put the figure in its stand (I decided to leave the large stand as it is a large figure) and then drill, pin, and glue the top hat in place for a strong seal.
The photo below shows the clipper I used to snip the pins down to the desired length.
Wa la!! The completed project! Simple and so cool!
Finally, it can't hurt to repeat some of the photos of the shots of the specially converted figures, now ready for priming and painting.
Books and Media for the period.
There is a variety of media one can get if you wish to explore this period of American history in more depth. Please remember, if you order through these links you are supporting this website.
First, once again, we have this wonderful set of rules.
Second, we have Herbert Asbury's classic yet sensationalized work, "Gangs of New York." Asbury was writing in the 1920s about life in the mid-nineteenth century and historians who look it over pretty much universally feel he was more interested in entertaining the reader than sticking to the facts and presenting a historically accurate document. It's an entertaining read that has been through several editions, but should not be taken as gospel. This is probably why when you look for more details and other sources on some of the things he describes you simply don't find them, as it is likely that they never existed.
Tyler Anbinder's "Five Points: The 19th Century New York City Neighborhood that Invented Tap Dance, Stole Elections, and Became the World's Most Notorious Slum," is a more serious history of the time and place written by a contemporary author. The two books at times contradict each other.
The Great Riots of New York is a late nineteenth century work that describes historical events as the author understood them to have happened. It is probably one of the sources Asbury used to write his book and parts of it are well worth reading to understand this period.
Yes, there was a big Hollywood movie based on these things and the events in Asbury's book. Perhaps unexpectedly, I was not a particularly big fan of the film, neither are the people at TVAG either by the way, they make that clear in the introduction to their wonderful rules, and it is also not particularly accurate in its depiction of history. Dates are mixed and some of the details not quite right. Nevertheless, if you are going to game this period, it's gotta be a "must-see" film so, if you wish, consider buying it through this link.
I was a bigger fan of a much lesser known BBC-America show called "Copper," which portrayed the adventures of a New York City police detective during the American Civil War. The show ran for two short seasons only and the actual number of episodes is a bit limited but it was a very interesting series and gives an interesting depiction of the underside of the City of New York at the time, even if it does not mention any of Asbury's gangs. Be forewarned that is a very dark and at times difficult to watch series but very well done. For instance, several episodes of the first season deal with the main character's attempts to get a 12 year old prostitute off of the streets and into a better life. She is portrayed disturbingly realistically. The situation is complicated when it turns out she is fleeing an abusive, yet completely legal, marriage to a man three or four times her age, and the legal options under the laws of the time are quite limited when he announces he wants her back. (The age of marriage at that time was much, much lower than now.) Worth watching if the period interests you and you can stomach dark materials.
Please be aware-
while there are only two seasons of the show available, they are being sold in several different packages so there are six items listed below.
And one more time, the awesome rules . . .
Finally, my books . . .
Yeah, I've written books. Please check them out and see if they interest you.